Approximation and Refinement Techniques for Hard Model-Checking Problems

Approximation and Refinement Techniques for Hard Model-Checking Problems Mihaela Bobaru (née Gheorghiu) Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Computer Science University of Toronto 2009 Formal verification by model checking verifies whether a system satisfies some given correctness properties, and is intractable in general. We focus on several problems originating from the usage of model checking and from the inherent complexity of model checking itself. We propose approximation and iterative refinement techniques and demonstrate that they help in making these problems tractable on practical cases. Vacuity detection is one of the problems, relating to the trivial satisfaction of properties. A similar problem is query solving, useful in model exploration, when properties of a system are not fully known and are to be discovered rather than checked. Both of these problems have solution spaces structured as lattices and can be solved by model checking using those lattices. The lattices, in the most general formulation of these problems, are too complex to be implemented efficiently. We introduce a general approximation framework for model checking with lattices and instantiate this framework for the two problems, leading to algorithms and implementations that can obtain efficiently partial answers to the problems. We also introduce refinement techniques that consider incrementally larger lattices and compute even the partial answers gradually, to further abate the size explosion of the problems. Another problem we consider is the state-space explosion of model checking. The size of system models is exponential in the number of state variables and that renders model checking intractable. We consider systems composed of several components running concurrently. For such systems, compositional verification checks components individually to avoid composing an entire system. Model checking an individual component uses